Even if you’re not an oatmeal cookie fan, you’ll love this ice cream. Strawberry. Of all the low-calorie ice cream brands on the market, Halo Top is indisputably the most popular one—perhaps because they've got nearly 50 flavors from which you can choose from. We’ll keep it simple – we love ice cream. Fruity flavors is where Halo Top T-H-R-I-V-E-S, we realized pretty quickly. However, upon tasting this flavor, symptoms may include systematically slipping back into your 10-year-old Ugg boots. 17. Lauren Burkholder. West Chester University. Like, to-the-point-of-no-return rich. "It's sweet and fine," another said. 0. pancakerunner Member Posts: 4,683 Member Member Posts: 4,683 Member. ©2020 Group Nine Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. While the newest, seasonal flavor seemingly harks back to summers spent spooning burst blueberries piled with sugary dough clusters, this pint results in that rather thick, blueberry yogurt-like taste. This version does not (where are the graham crackers?!) It's fantastic; need I say more? Strawberry is a classic and Halo Top did a really good job of getting that flavor. So if you want that flavor, then buy this one! Halo Top: We Ate (& Ranked) All The Flavors So You Don’t Have To 1. It’s the kind of ice cream that doesn’t leave you feeling disgustingly ill after consuming only a handful of licks. You don’t have to worry about unexpected, flying spurts of yogurt staining your clothes. The pervasive syrup flavor was lessened by the dairy, one assumes, but Pancakes & Waffles was still incredibly maple-forward. We decided to make Halo Top so we could enjoy ice cream as regular part of our diets, starting from 320 calories per tub. Welcome back babes! Really nice blend of nutty, chocolatey flavor with a satisfying texture. THIS VIDEO IS NOT SPONSORED! It should come as no surprise that Red Velvet, chocolate cake’s beet-tinged cousin, is wonderfully packaged into a strikingly blood-red ice cream form, one peppered with hunks of brownies. Halo Top's dairy-free line up has been excluded from this ranking because we're talking ice cream here. The overpowering banana flavor here confused a lot of people, especially because its dairy-free counterpart was one of our favs. 20th: Peanut Butter Cup (3.2 stars) / "Tastes good, but where are the actual PB cups?" Ever since Halo Top unleashed a roster of low-calorie ice cream packed in colorfully stylized pints, hordes of millennials -- we’re talking those tear-stricken, newly single millennials and dieters in search of non-chalky ice cream supplements -- could pull one or two (or several) pints from the freezer and polish off an entire carton. I eat Halo Top all the time. Oatmeal Cookie almost feels too healthy… even for low-cal ice cream. Unless you’ve been living under a rock, you’ve probably heard of Halo Top Ice Cream. . As far as flavor, though? But how does Halo Top really stack up? The Ultimate Ranking Of Halo Top Flavors 1. After trying all 17 flavors, we can say we’re actually obsessed, though our … Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. So from all your devoted fans, thank you from the bottom of our now stevia-caked hearts, for transforming our beloved cookie dough into guilt-free ice cream. At least it's edible, right? Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. Chocolate may seem like a pretty average flavor to top this ranking, but there was... 2. Mint Chip. Hey guys! While people enjoyed the chunkiness the dough provided, they felt it hard to take more than a few bites of this flavor. It's all up from here! The Halo Top section in my local store has been kind of sad and half-stocked for a while. This one was the most chocolatey of the new flavors … Chocolate. I suppose if you’re into slurping frothy, sugar-drenched coffee drinks tinged with caramel and crowned with pillows of whipped cream -- without all the added sugar -- then you’re golden with this flavor. Then we noticed it tasted delicious and decided to sell our ice cream. Lots to like about this flavor: "Equal parts chocolate, almond, and crunch," one person succinctly explained. "OMG, it's so heavy it hurts": The Chocolate Hazelnut Story. Nothing but nice things to say here: The Delish team is all in on Black Cherry and its "very good cherry chunks.". Rating: 4.5 spoons 3. And it should come as no surprise, then, that the whole pint boasts 360 calories -- the most caloric of Halo Top’s line. Then we named it Halo Top. I came in with high hopes for the Candy Bar Halo Top and I wasn’t disappointed. This pretty much felt like eating straight syrup. The flavor was nice, the texture was solid, but it left you with a lot of chewing to do. All 24 Halo Top Flavors, Ranked by Taste 1. Comments on Halo Top's version ranged from "weird aftertaste" to "it's floral?" Birthday Cake. … Don't worry, I’m still cradling the pint, fishing out those brownie pieces and watching my tongue turn cherry red. Oatmeal Cookie. But this version felt a little bit too salty and not enough sweet. Perhaps most importantly, though, is Halo Top’s willingness to channel the visceral nostalgia of a youthful, fast metabolism: days spent scraping raw cookie dough from the depths of a mixing bowl and licking drippy, cookie dough-studded cones plopped precariously atop cake cones. Nineteen pints and a frightening amount of spoons later, here’s how they each hold up: Now I know there are people out there who are firm believers that nuts are undeniably inseparable from ice cream (I hear you, Rocky Road people). "This is refreshing!" That's a big difference. Another baked good-type flavor, which not only tasted "summer-y," but it also felt really "comforting and happy," to one tester. That’s not bad, necessarily (if you’re into that kind of thing), and the big hunks of pie dough swirled throughout certainly don’t hurt. 19th: Lemon Cake (3.22 stars) / "Just OK." 18th: Pistachio (3.25 stars) / "Very creamy, sweet . The flavor is robustly peppermint -- but most importantly not horribly similar to your toothpaste -- and it feels and tastes so much like a fully sugar-drenched version that while you’re shoving spoonful after spoonful of it into your mouth you’ll question how the whole pint is only 320 calories. Candy Bar. … June 17, 2018 by … It was one of the OG flavors, and the base literally tastes like cake batter so you can FEEL like you’re being bad and licking the bowl of a freshly baked cake when rly you’re sitting in sweatpants and sadly eating a pint of diet ice cream alone LOL! The Strawberry Halo Top is another flavor that ' s just " eh. Since keto diets are very carb focused, I'd say it's worth trying the Halo Top Keto Ice Cream line. Between the rounds of soft cookie dough and liberal peppering of chocolate chips, chocolate chip cookie dough is easily Halo Top’s best flavor. This was a fave all around, with a crisp and cool mint flavor and perfect amount of chocolatey flakes and... 2. Halo Top has an ever-growing roster of flavors, and I didn’t try every single one for this taste test. Will it satisfy your chocolate cravings? This take on chocolate ice cream is all the things you'd hope and expect a good one to be: rich, complex, and sweet on the finish. The creamy chocolate ice cream isn’t merely spotted with roasted peanuts (and plenty of stevia, of course) -- there are swirls of caramel, too, and with that first lick comes a deep-seated hankering to repeatedly listen to that sweet, sweet sound of tearing open a brand-new candy bar. Best and Worst Halo Top Flavors Just in Time For Summer: The Definitive Ranking of Halo Top Ice Cream, From Worst to Best. 7. All 46 Of Halo Top's Flavors, Ranked 46 Rainbow Swirl. halo top. Cookies & Cream. But Halo Top Peaches & Cream is by far their best fruity flavor, and manages to best even some of the more complex, decadent dessert ones. Do they have any exciting new flavors? And let’s be honest, everyone at some point in their life (probably!) You know your girl LOVES Halo Top ice cream so I had to test the 10 new flavors! We don't need to get into the gritty details—though the word "gritty" was mentioned quite a few times in passing. And, each scoop is a good source of protein. For everyone else who’s on the side of right (welcome! So rich! May 23, 2019. You love ice cream too. Coming in at the top of all Halo Top flavors is the Birthday... 2. But then again, if it was littered with hunks of cookies, it surely wouldn’t be 280 calories. 20th: Peanut Butter Cup (3.2 stars) / "Tastes good, but where are the actual PB cups?" No one had anything but "yup, this is GOOD" to say about this flavor. Whatever that means. Chocolate Almond Crunch. This one was only slightly upstaged by its dairy-containing companion. To put that into perspective, our favorite ice cream has about 19 grams per pint. Nonetheless, I have agreed to remain unwaveringly unbiased in this Very Important line of duty when it comes to the rest of Halo Top’s nut flavors. It isn’t overboard with the lemon flavor and has a nice smooth finish. If you were one of those children, here’s that same exact flavor, finally (!) Again, Candy Bar was not a big hit with our team. Our New Cookie Tins Are The Sweetest Gift, You Can Buy Baby Yoda Macarons At Williams Sonoma, This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. You go into a taste test thinking you know what Cookies & Cream tastes like...until now. Maybe it's because we've shifted our brains from Christmas flavors to Valentine's Day ones, but this pint missed the mark, in our opinion. The takeaway from this pint is that low-cal ice cream does have the potential to be super rich. Lemon Cake is simply a sweet, slightly lemon-like ice cream that’s more similar to vanilla than it is to lemon. This flavor tasted exactly like a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup, which we... 3. Blueberry Crumble. Enjoy! For as much as people were not into Gingerbread House, they were very much into Red Velvet. Ah, don’t you wish everything s’mores-flavored burst with that marvelously burnt and smoky punch? I happened to love it, but the overwhelming office opinion was that it was too "perfume-y.". Pretty much everyone called it "yummy.". Here's the scoop (lol) and the definitive ranking of the Halo Top ice cream flavors from eh to YASSS. Certainly, but at a cost: It’s far too easy to eat it straight from the pint, only to look down and discover the spoon has scraped the cardboard bottom. In fact, some people will … The mint here is delightfully not that fake green color, but more of an off-white cream, punctured only by a slew of mini chocolate chips scattered throughout the carton. Non-existent. Remember your first sip of coffee, one heavily laced with chocolate and at the minimum three sugar packets so you could more easily choke it down? "Tastes like creamy coffee," an editor noted. While a lot of flavors' dairy-free counterparts ranked super high on this list, Candy Bar's was not one of them. Chocolate. Another perfectly nice flavor that was enjoyed but not raved about. I know, the suspense was killing you. Once upon a time Gogurt was all the rage. Halo Top, flavor rankings and which to avoid. We'll spare you most of the comments the Delish crew had to say about Rainbow Swirl and leave you with this: One staffer called it "seasoned Play-Dough." There are diehard fans of this Halo Top flavor, and for good reason. Strawberry. Sure, that sounds nice in theory, but a bowl full of it is quite aggressive. There is a special spot in ice cream purgatory for this sin of Rainbow Swirl. Pistachio Well, meet Halo Top’s verifiable palate cleansing pint: pistachio. Between the rounds of soft cookie dough and liberal peppering of chocolate chips,... 2. This flavor felt "luxurious"—a true cake-like experience, from start to finish. Here’s the innocuous vanilla -- one that’s not too vanilla, dare I say. Nothing inherently bad, just a bit odd. Now, we understand that Halo Top is a healthy, low-cal ice cream substitute, but this flavor is lacking the richness and total indulgence that we need from chocolate, earning it a low spot on our ranking list. Most have chunks of fruit, chocolate, or other flavor-relevant bits sprinkled within, an appreciated touch that helps the dessert stand out. Halo Top’s New Flavor Tastes Exactly Like A PB&J, Halo Top's Releasing 7 New Ice Cream Flavors, Exclusive: Halo Top's Got A New Holiday Flavor, Halo Top's New Flavor Is So Perfect For Spring. © Photo Courtesy of Halo Top Halo Top Pops Halo Top Pops are made with creamy, ultra-filtered skim milk and offer a good source of protein … OK, but where are the cookies? This was one of the few flavors that really didn't feel like an indulgence. Gingerbread House. The mint here is delightfully not that fake green color, but more of an off-white cream, punctured only by... 3. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io, All The Restaurants That Are Open On Christmas, All The Grocery Stores That Are Open On Christmas. People came out hard for this classic combo: "Who wouldn't want to eat this? That salty-sweet combo is an eruption of magic and heaven and puppies on your taste buds. ), you’d be remiss not to dive into this pint brimming with bits of salt and ribbons of sticky caramel. in actual dessert form. No one loved it. If you are looking for a flavor that is light and refreshing, Lemon Cake will do just the trick! This dairy-free flavor reminded us of banana Laffy Taffys and, therefore, of childhood. … S'mores. Absolutely outstanding. 1. As the resident, self-proclaimed ice cream connoisseur, it seemed only fitting that I sample each flavor. Another flavor you'd think would be difficult to pull of without dairy, and yet..."Yeah, this tastes like Thin Mints.". 19th: Lemon Cake (3.22 stars) / "Just OK." 18th: Pistachio (3.25 stars) / "Very creamy, sweet . DRUM ROLL PLEASE…….Peanut Butter Cup takes the gold medal in the Halo Top Flavor Olympics! Caramel Macchiato. With peach puree concentrate and (a few) peach pieces scattered throughout, this base is really vibrant, flavorful, and refreshing. There’s plenty of cream, for sure, but the cookies? Maybe it's the lack of dairy that allowed SO MUCH CINNAMON to overpower everything else here, but there was just...a lot of cinnamon happening. "Would eat this every day of my life," one coworker exclaimed. Each pint has 20 grams of protein & only 280-380 calories. Do you agree? more than one person noted of the Lemon Cake flavor. We don't need to get into the gritty details—though the... 44 Candy Bar (Dairy-Free). We tried all 17 Halo Top flavors — here's our ranking 1. In case you haven’t, Halo Top is a high-protein ice cream that promises to bring all your favourite things about regular ice cream without the guilt. The consensus was people would just rather have candy, straight. Hold the dairy, not the flavor. "Not enough oatmeal flakes here," one oatmeal-loving staffer mentioned. The Answer Is... Disney's Festive Cookie Butter Milkshake Is Insane. Everyone liked vanilla bean. Though the flavor was innocuous, it was so much so that there wasn't much to say about it. Review starts at 5:18 of the new @halotopcreamery ice cream flavors, releasing today! But there was one comment about it's "extremely sweet" flavor, so here we are at number 3. No matter the time of year, we're here for crumbly pie bits mixed into spiced ice cream. Like, super rich. If you’re in search of a tart, overly lemony ice cream, I’ll spare you a trip to the grocery store. -- it’s mostly a creamy base that’s only somewhat reminiscent of marshmallow, plus a showering of petit chocolate chips (it’s really more like vanilla chocolate chip). We’ll go ahead and eat a ton. About Halo Top. Which just leaves us at & cream. Carin ranked this one as her #1 of the new Halo Top flavors, and it was my #2 pick. has dreamt of sitting down and eating a whole cake in one sitting. I did not think chocolate chip cookie dough would be as good as it was. If you’ve never had Halo Top, here’s the 101: The company prides itself on producing low-sugar, protein-packed, and all-natural products, all under the premise that one pint merely boasts anywhere between 240 and 360 calories -- aka about one serving size of leading ice cream brands like Häagen-Dazs and Ben & Jerry’s (although, let’s be honest, no one really adheres to those laughably small serving sizes). If you’re the monster who prefers to keep savory separated from sweet, thank you very much, you’re certainly entitled to your opinion. Here's where the raving began. . Just barely sliding ahead of Chocolate Mocha Chip is the regular Chocolate Halo Top. In other words, this was THE BEST. People much preferred this maple-heavy flavor to every variation of Pancakes & Waffles. 13 Halo Top Ice Cream Flavors, Ranked BRING BACK THE BREAKFAST FLAVORS!!!! Below are all the flavors I have tried. They are also the base of many of these ice creams pints, so I figured they would get some kind of assessment anyway. Tess Koman covers breaking (food) news, opinion pieces, and features on larger happenings in the food world. With Halo Top being relatively expensive and "healthy" ice cream being a hit or miss, I thought this would be good for those who haven't tried it yet or those who are looking to try new ones. Why the two felt similar, no one could really identify. Enlightened tastes like it is made out of a mix of chemicals. 45 Candy Bar. That’s chocolate mocha chip for you: a mousse-like chocolate base churned with bitter espresso and bits of chocolate. By replacing some sugar with organic sweeteners such as stevia, Halo Top offers over 20 delicious flavors, many falling under 300 calories a pint. Halo Top just released seven keto-friendly ice cream flavors. Another divisive flavor, but this one ended up near the top. Chocolate Almond Crunch It appears to me to be a Halo knock off in terms of the flavors being sold and the packaging. It really was very light, fluffy, and nice. Lest you begin worrying about how long it'll take you to cycle through all of them and find your favorite, we went ahead and tried them all for you. Chocolate Mocha Chip. Sign up here for our daily Thrillist email, get Eatmail for more food coverage, and subscribe here for our YouTube channel to get your fix of the best in food/drink/fun. It’s the simplest and classic flavors where Halo Top excels, and that’s the case for their chocolate, which leans closer to milk than dark and reminds me of licking a Fudgsicle, that light chocolate taste refreshing and cool as it slides down your throat. It’s splattered with vanilla beans (a nice treat! Oatmeal … Not only were people impressed by the amount of oatmeal flakes throughout, but they also thought the could down the pint in its entirety. This low-calorie, high-protein, low-sugar, all-natural ice cream brand is known for never lacking in the flavor department while being a better alternative to traditional ice cream.. Thousands of Influensters have given Halo Top the nod — be sure to try these Influenster favorite flavors! I decided to skip the plain chocolate and vanilla flavor because those just can’t win a taste test on different flavors. This seasonal flavor brought the staff a lot of joy. They’re much too tough to munch on, especially because they’re uncooked, and a rather unwelcome surprise when you’re expecting something more similar to an actual oatmeal cookie. "I love love looove a mint that's not too minty" was what people mostly took away from this. "Yum.". "I want to top all kinds of pie with this stuff," was a good way of putting it.